Bob Vila's Old Home Renovation

Historic Home Renovation Ideas
for the Front Porch

Bob Vila's old home renovation project is great for anyone considering renovating or updating their existing front porch. He walks you through the historic home renovation of an 1892 home that had once become a boarding house.



Bob explains the process of removing the balustrade (railings), porch decking, and inspecting the framing on this colonial revival front porch in the Elmwood district of Providence RI.

old home renovation

1892 Home

Much of this content comes from a video that Bob had but is no longer available. This 1892 home has amazing oak moldings, built-ins, and an inspiring staircase but like many homes from that era, it has been neglected over the years.

old home renovation old home renovation

The central focus of this grand house is a front porch in desperate need of renovation.

old home renovation

The porch decking is pressure treated lumber but should be made from mahogany to maintain authenticity.

old home renovation The balusters are not spaced correctly because many of them have been repaired over the years. (See our handy baluster spacing tips.)

The top and bottom rails have also decayed to the point where the entire balustrade needs to be replaced.

home renovation tips

It appears the original column bases were replaced with pressure treated wood also.

Old Home Renovation Demolition

Demolition of the railings is the first step. Care must be taken, however, to ensure section profiles are recovered intact so they can be replicated for replacement. As you can see in the photos below, the railing section is beyond saving and must be replaced.

home renovation tips home renovation tips

home renovation tips

home renovation ideas Only one finial remains (photo at right) and was removed in two pieces. These, too, will be sent to the mill for replication.

Somewhat humorously, the contractor notes obvious evidence of lots of putty and paint which was used to repair and cover up imperfections on the balustrade over the years and exclaims:

"Putty and paint makes the job what it ain't".

Several balusters (photo below) are removed to send to the mill works for replication and replacement.

home renovation ideas

There are also obvious signs of rotting, lots of putty, and damage to the bottom rails as seen in the photo below. Most of the damage was caused by placing the bottom rail directly on the floor boards. The bottom rails must be replaced and positioned off the floor to avoid water damage in the future.

home renovation ideas

Once the pieces to be milled are saved, the remaining balustrade is removed as part of the old home renovation process - as depicted in the photo below.

home renovation ideas

Column and Column Bases

The next step is to jack up the roof so the porch columns can be removed for stripping and repair. Note that the porch columns are solid with an opening through the center. Without the hole for air flow, the columns would rot from the inside out.

Column bases must also be replaced due to rotting and they are not structurally correct to carry the load.

historic home renovation

historic home renovation historic home renovation



Porch Decking Removal

The existing porch decking is made from treated lumber and did not stand the test of time. Each board is removed to expose the framing underneath.

old home renovation

It is extremely important to inspect the framing when conducting an old home renovation. It is noted that insufficient nails and joist hangars were used to construct the frame for this porch. This needs to be corrected before new decking is installed.

old home renovation

The porch flooring was supported by an inadequate span supported by a piece of wood on the ground. A new Sonotube footing needs to be poured and the framing needs to span the distance from the house to the outside foundation wall.

porch repairs

porch repairs

This concludes Part 1 of a four-part series of this Elmwood District old home renovation.

Bob Vila logo Bob Vila, the Dean of Home Renovation and Repair Advice, is well known for his television show "This Old House". Now you can access Bob's myriad tips and advice, ask questions and receive video responses, and catch up on the most innovative ideas for home improvement all through his website.

See more of Bob Vila's renovation of this wonderful home and other projects at

Our Home Renovation Tips

Here are a few old home renovation ideas to consider when remodeling or renovating your home:
  • Determine what features need to be replicated and take great care when removing them
  • Determine what can be recycled, reused, or discarded
  • Determine how local building codes may affect your renovation
  • If paint is involved, ensure extra paint is left for touch-ups
  • Get everything in writing; do not assume anything
  • Find a reputable contractor

Disclaimer: The information provided here is for informational purposes only. Because every project is different and individual DIY skills vary, it's best to consult a licensed contractor about your specific project.


/ / Old Home Renovation


Enjoy shopping wayfair
Enjoy Shopping Wayfair (affiliate)

Helpful Links

Popular Pages

Please Join Us Here Also

Join us on Facebook for porch talk Join us on Pinterest Subscribe to get our updates. Thank you!

Our Sponsors
Shop for Porch Parts at Vintage Woodworks.
Vintage Woodworks for Your Porch Parts

The Porch Store
Porch Store - Custom Porch Products

Aluminum screen doors from PCA Products
PCA Products Complement any Home

Copyright© 2008-2019
All rights reserved.

Content and photos may not be reproduced
in any way without our written permission.

small rocking chair

Get up to 4 free local contractor estimates for work you need done
Find a Local Contractor

We Love Our Sponsors
Shop for Porch Parts at Vintage Woodworks
Vintage Woodworks for Your Porch Parts

The Porch Store
Porch Store - Custom Porch Products

Aluminum screen doors from PCA Products
PCA Products Complement any Home

Enjoy shopping wayfair
Enjoy Shopping Wayfair (affiliate)

Get Our Newsletter,
Front Porch Appeal
and a bonus!
Learn more!

Subscribe and also receive our eBook
Free eBook - Maximize Your Homes Curb Appeal We will use your email address only to send our newsletter and this helpful ebook on curb appeal!
Enjoy our back issues.

What's New
What is new or updated on our site
See Our Latest Updates

Get Our Porch Ideas Generator eBook
Front Porch Ideas Generator eBook
Ten Before & After Case Studies
Showing the Difference a Porch Makes!
Only $9.97

See Our Porch Illustrator eBook
Porch Illustrator Vol 1 & Vol 2 eBook
Over 300 Pages of Porch Illustrations
to Absolutely Inspire!
Just $9.97

Search Our Site

Porch Ideas Network
Porch Ideas Network
Listen to Our Podcasts
Plus Featured Builders and Landscapers

Have a wonderful day!

small rocking chair
We may earn a commission by referring you to some products on merchant sites. See our disclosure policy. Thank you.

Front Porch Designs Home | Return to Top
Contact Us | About Us | Advertise with Us | Search | Site Map
Media | Privacy Policy | Disclosure | Legal Notice | What's New

XML RSS   Add to My Yahoo!  
By Mary and Dave Morris, Copyright © 2008-2019 All rights reserved.
Content and photos may not be reproduced or copied in any way without our express written permission.

Page copy protected against web site content infringement by Copyscape